We stayed at Xtabi once in April. I don't immediately remember the cottage #, but it didn't have A/C and we were uncomfortable trying to sleep. In the cottage we stayed at, we also heard road noise pretty easily. I honestly can't remember if we ate at the restaurant. I know can be expensive, though. The property was quiet (as far as other people being around) and chill, as you can imagine up on the cliffs. It is the only time we have stayed up on the cliffs. The stay confirmed to us that we are beach people.