Ditto on the West End. Ivan's for sure. Rockhouse has a few private dining nooks down at waters edge which are very romantic but our experience was that they tend to forget about you down there and your order may be cold by the time you get it. LTU Cliff is our favorite. Over the years I've seen birthdays, anniversaries, and even wedding dinners celebrated there. Let them know about your anniversary and they will fix you up. Chicken Lola and Hunter Schnitzel are great non-seafood dishes and prices are a little lower there than the others mentioned.

On the beach I agree with Kuyaba. Be sure to have coconut pie and coffee for dessert and you will be very happy.