We have had many anniversary dinners in Jamaica. My birthday and our anniversary are two days apart and we usually celebrate them in Negril.
Funny story. We really enjoy staying at Tensing Pen. We are dog people and the dogs at Tensing love us. They would sleep on our porch and guard us. They would even bark at security at night as they did their rounds.
We scheduled to have our anniversary dinner on the side of the cliffs on a small platform (very cool and special spot). The dogs would not let the server down the stairs. They made me put up the dogs so they could serve us. As soon as dinner was done, I went straight to the pen and let them out.
Tensing is a great spot for a special dinner. This year we did the love nest at Catcha for our anniversary and Tensing for my birthday. Cannot go wrong with either place.