K4,

Sorry to hear about your dog! Hopefully the authorities will deal with the problem.

I have never owned or rented property in Negril or Jamaica, but have been traveling to Jamaica for over 30 years. First trip in 1992. My eighth trip since April 2022 is in a few weeks.

My suggestion would be to rent first and feel out where you might buy later.
Renting gives you more flexibility to move around and try different locations.
The expats that I know that live in and around Negril prefer to have properties that have bars on the windows.
Air conditioning can be expensive due to the cost of electricity.

I love Jamaica year round, but prefer October thru June. July, August and September can be too hot and humid for me. However, one of the benefits is the sea can be bathtub warm!

Wishing you the very best with you future plans.

VVHT aka Happy