Ratty,

Just my humble opinion....

Country Store at Sunshine Village is Brand New, Hilo in Boardwalk Village is almost brand new (about a year and 1/2 old).
Both are excellent improvements to Negril!
I have shopped both stores.

Country Store is located in Sunshine Village at the beginning of the West End/Cliffs.
Hilo is located at Boardwalk Village at the north end of Long Bay across from Country Country and Treehouse.
So depending on where you are staying, one might be more convenient than the other.
April 2023 I was staying at White Sands and the new Hilo was very convenient to walk to almost every other day.

HiLo is bigger and has more selection.

I'm not too fussy about pricing, so I can't give an opinion on prices. I'm more of a convenience shopper and if I'm downtown, I'll stop at Country Store, if I'm up on the beach road, I might stop at HiLo (especially if I'm going the NCB ATM).

Enjoy,

VVHT aka Happy