So I'll be coming down myself in late February for 10 days and I'm thinking of renting a car for the first time for convenience and exploring the island somewhat (also, with a private roundtrip Mobay transfer costing $200 now and taxis, back and forth to the cliffs, during the week costing $30 a trip, it doesn't seem that much more costly than being a pedestrian).

I'm looking thru Expedia at the different prices and rental companies (Europcar, Fox, U-Save, Budget, Ace, Alamo, Enterprise, Hertz) and I'm looking to get some feedback on...

1) Best rental companies for the money you spend (based on their service, quality of car, hidden fees/costs)

2) Pro/Cons of getting a rental that aren't obvious (yeah, I know, left side of road, jamaicans are aggressive drivers... etc)

I appreciate all input!