Kristine- I know what you mean, for many years I told everyone that the BEST Pina Colada was at Margaritaville (and it is probably still good, I didn't have one there this year, I might not have had one last time either) but this last trip we had dinner at Pushcart on my birthday and that Pina Colada was perhaps the best one I have EVER had....it was amazingly good. I couldn't get over it...I should have had more! lol
Pushcart is the restaurant on Rockhouse Hotel's property (they have two restaurants now, the main Rockhouse restaurant, and then the Pushcart). It used to be Pirate's Cave Bar if you are familiar with where that is....if not, just head to Rockhouse, you can't miss it