I recommend Banana Shout for a great little rustic place that is literally on the edge of the cliff situated between Rick's Cafe and Catcha Falling Star. Dolphin Bay and Dolphin View are great little cottages and go for $100 or less a night. My husband and I could stay anywhere and yet we went to Banana Shout last November and returned again this November. Milo and Marianne are wonderful. There is nothing fancy here, but great people and an amazing location with a fantastic price.