Westender is lovely but it is OUT THERE. Not just a "little further" out of town - a lot further. Now, they do have vans that shuttle their guests into town and the beach I believe. If you want isolation and quiet you might consider that.

There are so many cliff properties. As stated, for what you are used to and like you might want to look at Rockhouse, Tensing Pen even Xtabi's Sea Front cabins.

Negril Escape is a nice property in a great location but is definitely nothing fancy.