Hey Rust - there is not a bad room at Cathcha. By far my favorite place to stay in Negril.
Have not stayed in Pisces but it looks plenty big and not near the road. New pool and amazing decor. Sea views are AMAZING!!!! Food is also OUTSTANDING but moderately priced so I ate offsite and onsite to save some $$.

The two bedrooms are gorgeous and you would feel like ROCK STARS!!! IF you can swing it$ go for it you will not regret. If its good friend sharing the cost is more economical....just depends if you guys need privacy
Scroll down for pics of Pisces.

http://www.negrilonestop.com/catchaf...r_photos.shtml