I would pick Option 2

I did a quick AI deal/special once for the same reasoning as you and I hated it. I made a strong vow that very moment that I would NEVER go to Jamaica again for any less than 7 days (at least).
In my opinion, a short trip is worse than a long wait for a long trip.


However, with that said, if I had money and time, I would go as many times as possible in a year lol
But with your choices I would pick Option 2, definitely