I stayed at Xtabi superior rooms two years in a row

Just for reference, in all of my trips to Negril the only other place I have ever booked more than once is Catcha Falling Star (which is my all time favorite place on earth)

So yes, I love Xtabi, and though we may not stay there now, we definitely would stay there again (let's say if Catcha was booked) and we still visit them multiple times throughout each and every one of our trips.

If you get one of the top floor rooms like 15 or so, you can still catch a glimpse of the water from your balcony and still see a nice sunset.
The rooms are large, have a/c and are IMO one of the best values on the cliffs. Plus just a walk right across the street to the ocean, bar, restaurant. Can't beat it for location and value as far as I am concerned.
Go for it!