I've stayed at Treehouse twice and never knew about the "rule" -- once was in the ocean front suite, which had kitchen area and we had our own liquor for sure, the other time we ate and drank out, was a short trip. But both times I've seen guests out on their patios/balconies with coolers of drinks, which I asuumed they brought in, though I guess they could have been from the bar -- maybe Gail will see this and clarify.

I think Seasplash should be in the running for sure. Great new space at restaurant/bar, fabulous grounds/pool/hottub, great long-time staff. And the 1-bedroom suites are fabulous with full kitchen and lots of space. If you don't want that much space, a Jr. Suite is good too. Price is right these days too as they are finishing construction.

Seawind gets high marks from many reports I've read, and the restaurant there is good. No pool, though they have one at Garnedias across the street that guests are welcome to use. Lastly I think Idle Awhile looks fabulous, and I hear their restaurant Chill Awhile is great. But it's more pricey for sure and they don't have specials. But the look is really upscale Jamaican fabulous imho. When I win lotto ....