We have done both and would do both again. Basically, do you want a fun afternoon or do you want an all day adventure?

It will be pretty much a full day if you go to the Pelican Bar and I agree that you would probably want to do it with another tour. We did it with YS Falls. We loved getting out and seeing more of Jamaica, traveling through the different towns along the way and stopping off to eat at roadside places.

The Bar Crawl was probably the best time we've had on our 6 trips to Jamaica.

I would do both, if it is an option.