They haven't decided for sure, but are thinking of Grand Pineapple. Most everyone will be newbies (except for hubby, me, and our daughter) and so that I don't have to play super tour guide the whole time, an AI would be better. Selfish of me, huh? She would love the cliffs, but her fiancee has a nephew who will be 2 and the beach just seems safer for the baby. Our trip last year was our first non AI, and I would prefer that...but frankly, as long as I am in Negril...it's all good.