Perhaps grand pineapple on the beach. Small ai, right in the thick of things. I stayed there on my first reach many years ago, on my own. You still have that ai vibe, but can walk the beach and stop at restaurants, bars, vendors as you like. I decided within a couple of days that an ai wasn't really my thing since I was never there!

I am in Negril now, trying yet another hotel, I like to change it up each trip.

The cliffs are wonderful, will be moving there for my last two nights, but you are a little more insulated there....behind a gate at many properties, but excellent food and little bars if you venture out.

Let us know how it goes.