I think I would answer this question differently for different people/situations....for you guys I have to choose option B.
After reading all of your trip reports (absolutely loved them all, btw) I got a sense of who you guys are and how Negril inevitably cast it's spell on you both..love it!
I choose option B because I'd like to see you you keep it fresh - get back there asap! Just go experience more, explore more, learn the ropes more, stay new places, meet even more people(tourists/locals), try new places to eat/drink, take route taxi's, walk to town, try staying on the cliffs,etc.
Basically I'm hoping you remain addicted, Lol! I guess I'm just thinking since you've only been there this one time, a year is a long time to wait. Six months from now then again six months from then would really keep you in the zone
I do see the logic of saving money on airfare and having patience, but I'm still partial to option B
I think after your third trip you will really have a lot more perspective on it all and on what really works for you....then perhaps the next year you could be patient and wait for the two week vacation. After trip three there's no turning back anyway, regardless of time between visits...
I'm sure others may think the opposite for valid reasons, but this is just my opinion.
Whatever you decide, you really can't go wrong! Good Luck!!!
