mi know both places well and mi would go with Blue Cave Castle.......
sure Home Sweet Home has the pool and pretty similar location.......
but there is something truly special about Blue Cave Castle.......
and Ted's Hideaway food is off the chart at BCC.....and you can eat anywhere you want......
plus Petrona is a super sweet manager and Susan the owner cares about your stay.......
hey their both nice but mi think you will always think back after the vacation how special BCC was......
unless HSH is super cheap as compared to BCC........you know where I would stay.......lol
Cool Runnings, Marko