What if you split your stay and opted for another location at a cheaper rate (let's say Seastar or Catcha Falling Star Gardens, or the garden side rooms at Xtabi) and then with the money you saved from those nights you could opt for another room at Catcha for the remaining days at a higher rate if need be

I am definitely with booger on this one....any room at Catcha is a good room and worth it just to be on that property....there is no comparison anywhere else (IMO)