They stayed at Coco La Palm on their very first trip, they both loved it, but I think in her post she mentions that they considered staying there again since they loved it, but they really wanted to try something new

I would say look at Seasplash. You know we are cliff people but I have heard nothing but good reviews from the few on this board that have stayed there since the renovation. Perhaps even Jim is still running a boardie special,maybe?
I too think Kuyaba is nice, I would probably consider it if staying on the beach, but if the room you want is booked then I would say see what kind of deal you could get on Seasplash, or check out White Sands, that one sounds nice too.....but I am just agreeing with you, since I don't have any real beach experience to add.

Maybe check out NegrilOneStop to see what specials they are running through April?
Good luck!

Just so excited that you guys pushed the button! Woo Hoo