We have stayed at Banana Shout twice. We love Dolphin Bay. Nothing fancy, no frills. Great little cottage with the most amazing view. No A/C which was fine for us because we went both times in late November.

We did have Tree House for a few days and we liked the huge deck and the room was small but all you need. However, the bathroom is down the stairs and that took some getting used to and it is loud from the street noise.

Definitely choose Dolphin Bay or Dolphin View.

Milo and Marianne are wonderful and consider them friends and will do anything to make your stay perfect.