Xtabi or Rockhouse?

[marley9808]

Yes....Clarity is right, that changes my answer

If you want a recommendation for where I would pick...Catcha Falling Star, definitely.
Tensing Pen would be my runner up!

[Aud-A-Sea]

Haven't stayed at Rock House, though I have been on the property many times. Stayed in cottage #4 at Xtabi twice.

I like Xtabi and especially #4. However, I prefer the area around Rock House. Think the water is prettier and the area nicer. Just my opinion.