You CAN! lol
If you don't mind moving around a lot, It's possible.
We were faced with the same dilemna, I fell in love with all of those hotels you mentioned too.
We couldn't decide so we just booked all of them for our next reach.
Well, maybe you want to wait on that to hear how it turns out for us first.
We might end up over-exerting ourselves and advise all to avoid that approach
Home Sweet Home looks beautiful too - If you haven't read Guirigay's TR yet, I highly recommend it. It also has some awesome pictures of HSH.
http://negril.com/forum/showthread.p...light=giurigay