We are leaving from San Francisco in May and paying $580 each. We probably could have found cheaper but my husband wanted to fly Virgin. Those were actually decent ticket prices. RT from SFO to FLL for $257 a piece on Virgin. Then from Florida to MBJ we didn't want to fly Spirit (times didn't quite work and bag fees would have made any savings not worth the hassle of flying Spirit), so the only other option was Caribbean Air. If we weren't so picky about the airlines we could have done it for about $50 cheaper pp for the dates and times we were looking for.