Aww thank you Jesswade for the compliment on our TR! So glad you enjoyed it. Hearing that makes MY day!

I also agree with Bnewb, If you are staying long enough to split your trip between both properties I would go for it.
Seastar inn has such a great vibe, they really make you feel at home there. The food is amazing! I have some video footage of the grounds that I'll try to post soon.
I've never been to Charela Inn but it looks beautiful and I've heard a lot of great things about that property.