it's really apples and oranges in this case.............
one is directly on the beach........the other is on the road side of the cliffs and not on the water..........
one is kinda expensive.........one is kinda inexpensive..........
personally I would choose SeaStar Inn because overall it's a lot better setup for this guy............
it would be living it up big time at Charlea Inn being a solo guy and not worth the extra bucks.........

now comparing Charlea Inns sista property Mirage with SeaStar Inn would be more like oranges and oranges.........though Mirage is directly on da wata

Cool Runnings, Marko