Where should we eat?

[Clarity]

There isn't much I can add, you already have a plethora of amazing suggestions! I've only been to a small amount of the restaurants listed and they were great. I hope to one day try all of them

If you travel over to the beach end, I would recommend "Best of the West" for their Jerk Chicken. It's a great vibe, and I love their sauce. (It's a little milder than others I have tasted in Jamaica, but I just love it so much. I sopped up every lick of it with the thick tasty bread.. yummmm) "3 Dives" is amazing, no doubt... but "Best of the West" has my heart

It's a little shack with a jerk barrel in front. You'll find it across the street from Coco La Palm.