Why would it "change some folks mind about Seastar"?
Seastar has never hidden that it's not on the sea & offers an incredible & affordable vibe that is rare to find anywhere elsewhere in Negril!
Catcha Falling Star's policy is the same as it has been.
Catcha Falling Star for quite a few years now, has only allowed their paying room guests access to the property during the day with access to outside guests after 5pm in the restaurant & bar only.
In Tattoo's case...there was a wedding going on & access to non-room guests that evening was limited to reservations only...not really a big deal.
There's also other properties available to visit that have open access to non-room guests...Xtabi for example.