Glad I found some Catcha experts here!! We're coming home in November for 9 nts. Have stayed on the beach in the past at an all-inclusive. This time we have Idle Awhile booked but thought we'd split the trip and stay 3 nts on the cliffs. I would really like to try Catcha. Libra and Sagi are booked (darn, of course). Our choices are Pisces (like that its private but too small?) Gemini I & II (not so private cause its shared?) or Sun / Venus (been leaning away from those because I love the simple old authentic Jamaican feel??) . Any advise/comments would be greatly appreciated!!