This year we've decided to go Non AI. We've decided to split our stay between Idle Awhile and a few nights on the cliffs. Catcha has available the following....looking for advice. Libra and Sagi booked--Darn!!

Pisces....Is it too small?? We like the idea of our own cottage. I know its not the best view but the deck looks nice. Great price too (more money for drinks!!)
Gemini I & II...Both available but not sure how we'd like "sharing" a cottage??
Sun & Venus...Look nice, but I kinda like the old Jamaican feel of the other cottages ....not really looking for new and fancy.
Moon 2... Available but its only for the 2 of us, don't really need 2 bedrooms

Any advice you can share with me would be greatly apprieciated!!