Well the first night I had them was at Seastar... I thought, "Damn these things are good!" But then I had them at 3 Dives and thought.... "Oh these are awesome!" So I'm gonna go with 3 Dives... but I liked it every time I had it, which in JA is with every meal (almost)! Apparently they cook them with coconut milk. I liked everything I ate down there, and I'm pretty freakin' picky! I DID NOT like the Akee & Saltfish breakfast at Catcha...blaahhhhh! Although it looked pretty on my plate!