swept away would be a great choice. have stayed many times as well as many times non ai. both great. don't let them scare you about getting off property. go to a show one night (if you can stay up that late). prob want to book thru negril one stop . won't cost any more for you and they can assist on a room. ensure you are not next to the road or right by the dining area.. my only complaint about swept away is you have to wear hard soled shoes to get into a couple of the restaurants.