Ok then
RC1 is not bad at all, the only reason I suggested RC2 is because it is the most private, where RC1 is right next to the pool, but really the whole dang property is amazing.

Can I ask if you have checked out Catcha Falling Star, right next door?

It really depends on your style, as BS and TP are very different properties.
In an easy comparison I would say Banana Shout is like a cool Hippy Retreat artsy fun vibe where Tensing Pen is a high end luxury place
They are both cool, but very different so it would just depend on what you have in mind for your honeymoon.

Tensing Pen was very nice but we stayed there only once.....we splurged for our honeymoon and we did not regret it.

But our favorite property in all of Negril is Catcha and now we are spoiled by them and hardly stay anywhere else.

If you have any specific questions just let me know.
Plus there are a lot of fans of both places so you will probably get a lot more great advice and details.
Happy researching!