Riu Tropical Bay- OK, but on boat ride to cliffs, that long stretch of beach looked like so much more fun. Couldn't get wife to leave resort.
White Sands- nice place.
Legends- was nice enough, but didn't have mini fridge, and didn't know about renting them.
Beach House Villas- 2x -nice rooms, but has gotten too expensive in the last few years.
Blue Cave Castle- our only cliff stay, tower room. Was great with wind coming through windows at night, we called it the vortex, the way it swirled around the room.
NBCC- nice, large room
Coco La Palm- 2x- nice, but I like to be more center beach close walking distance to places at night.
Rooms- nice enough
Rondel Village- rooms were fine, but shade hard to find during the day.

9 for us, would like to try Catcha, and spend a couple of days at Aqua some trip.