Hmmm let me think...

Riu Tropical Bay - my first stay in Negril and nice to bring newbies who needed AI/fancy
Beachcomber Club - great place a few years ago to stay with a large group
Legends - ok but the beach was way too small for me
Merrills 2 - I enjoyed this smaller AI but this was to be my last AI
White Sands - that's it... I am hooked! This is the place for me.
Xtabi - tried out the cliffs and loved Xtabi, but I am a beach person