7 for me in 12 years and 17 trips.
In chronological order;
Charela Inn, simply the best on the beach IMHO.
The Blue Cave Castle, my happy place and my home in Negril!
Riu Tropical Bay, before it was remodeled and branded a "Palace". Was there for 3 nights, which was 2 too many.
Negril Treehouse, great place and Gail the owner is a terrific host and very civic minded. Plus the breakfast buffet is awesome.
Jah B's, nice little neighborhood but our cute little board house never cooled down at night.
Yellow Bird, fantastic value and great family vibe and the 2 for 1 dirty bananas can't be beat.
Kuyaba, Honeymoon suite and one of the new king suites. After eating there for years and years I was disappointed in the hotel side. All the little fine touches that made the restaurant so special were missing.
Even my beach loving Empress has decided she prefers the Castle most of all. We will be back at Charela in December for a wedding and I can't wait.
