This is such a great thread Topic, Gerry! I love reading everyone's list. I'm attracted to the places that people keep going back to over and over... that's a sign that it's a place definitely worth staying at on my next trip.

My own list is pretty short.. Only 2 places and you already know what they are, but I'll list them here anyway.

Grand Pineapple - Awesome staff and great food
Coco La Palm - Loved it - 2 pools, good happy hour specials and Best stretch of beach I've seen!

Hoping some day to reach the lucky seven number.

Looking to split our next trip between cliffs and beach. I'm thinking about possibly "Catcha" or "Xtabi". Still not sure....