All of the above suggestions are right on! The only two that I have not stayed in HSH and Oasis. With that said, I would highly recommend Catcha Gardens. Xtabi standard rooms are much smaller and a little more dated. However, they do have a great area to snorkel with easy access. That is a plus. They also have a great bar and restaurant. But Catcha Gardens rooms are larger with small refrig. (big plus) and the rooms are very well kept...with a new pool that is really perfection! LTU is right across the street with one gorgeous view as well as the gorgeous view at Xtabi. You really can't go wrong either way. Seastar is also in the mix, a little further from the water and the prices have increased somewhat but still a great place. Enjoy your trip and tell us all about it. The cliffs are perfection in my opinion...