Most romantic dining spot for my bride and me

[Phil & Cindy]

Having gotten down on one knee and asking Cindy to be my bride a back in 2010 at Woopies with Dennis and friends in attendance, we now return in 11 days as husband and wife. I really need some advise on where to take her for that once in a lifetime, most excellent and romantic dining experience that just makes us go "wow". I had the best meal in my life (up till now) at Catcha dining on lobster thermadore, so we will do that again but I am looking for the something different and special. What do you recommend?

[Sweetness]

Villa Sur Mer? Rooftop of Kuyaba?

If you talk with a manager and/or chef ahead of time you will be so pleased on how gracious they will be and how special they will make things for you.

[Jaherring]

I say, What coulkd be more romantic than crabs? A nice romantic meal at Bentleys Crab Shack would be my choice. Bentley will cook you up a nice plate of crabs and all the fixins'. Lots of little white lights and candles on the tables for that romantic evening.

I would also suggest Ivan's at Catch a Falling Star....very romantic place for a meal and drinks with a wonderful view of the sea.

[booger]

I say, What coulkd be more romantic than crabs? A nice romantic meal at Bentleys Crab Shack would be my choice. Bentley will cook you up a nice plate of crabs and all the fixins'. Lots of little white lights and candles on the tables for that romantic evening.

I would also suggest Ivan's at Catch a Falling Star....very romantic place for a meal and drinks with a wonderful view of the sea.

I was thinking the exact same thing about Bentley's. The setting is rustic and it is not right on the water, however the two of you entertained and fed by Bentley would be awesome...... Just remember to hit him up that morning or the day before to get on the same page as him. He'll also ask for a little payment up front. I gave him $30 if I remember correctly and that was to feed 4 people as well as to pick up some Red Stripes for the 4 of us. The $30 was not the entire meal cost, just a starter and when you see the meal the total cost will not be out of line.

[marley9808]

I personally think you can't get much better than Ivan's at Catcha (especially the Night of 100 candles dinner)

But since you asked for other ideas here would be my suggestions:
1) The Rock Table at Rockhouse. Call or email them and make arrangements ahead of time. It is a special table on the cliff all by itself, I think they only do a couple of seatings a night. You are all off by yourself and have your own server. It is very nice. There is no extra charge for that table you just have to reserve it. They also however have another option which is somewhat like the 100 candles dinner at Catcha.
It is located away from the restaurant out over by the massage hut and includes a set price and set menu


2) The Caves. This is a fancy AI property on the cliffs that has a dinner in a cave option. I originally thought that was only available for guests but I recently heard that they will offer it to outside guests so maybe check into that. Basically they set up a table inside a cave and fill it with candles. Sounds VERY romantic


Have fun whatever you choose, and congrats on the marriage!

[dash]

Booger, What was the meal cost for four people?

[Seveen]

i suggest Teddy's Hideaway at Blue Cave Castle :-)

[TizzyATX]

Congrats!! She's beautiful I have seen stuff about that dinner at the Caves, that marley mentioned and it looks like a really cool romantic experience....if your looking to go big

http://www.islandoutpost.com/the_caves/dining/

[booger]

Booger, What was the meal cost for four people?

I do not remember, but it wasn't out of line.....

[sevenmile]

nothing can be better than blue cave castle.
took my new fiance there last april after just getting engaged. teddy (chef) was the man, it was unreal!