My opinion on the positives and negatives of BCC vs HSH.

HSH pro's
Great Cliff setup
Pool
Hot tub
All rooms AC though we never use it
All rooms have a sea view
Charlie was a great on-site owner - He has sold though and I'm not sure when new ownership takes over
good value - we paid full price $110 a night in early february. I've heard you can do MUCH better than that at HSH in non-peak periods.
great location

HSH cons
little more weather-beaten than some of the other cliffside resorts
kitchen is good but there are a lot of great kitchens in Negril
restaurant/bar tab is separate from hotel bill and must be settled separately in cash

BCC pros
Nicer grounds and buildings
Teddy's Hideaway - a GREAT restaurant
Your staying in a castle
the cave
great value from the prices I've heard
great location

BCC cons
No pool
No hottub
so so sea access
AC only in some rooms?

I think you'd be happy at either one.

Shooting the Real Negril? Now there is an opening to a long winded philosophical discussion. I'll try to answer that like this - Find your groove, shoot your groove and what you get will by default be real.

Annnnndddd... get a good ride in from Mo Bay, every little ting gonna be alright.