Catchafallingstar is by far the best value for the money anywhere in the Caribbean. If you have a choice of the three, SSI, CFSG, or Catchafallingstar Pisces, and you are not single but with a special someone, do the Pisces by all means. This is five star quality at a three star price. You may never leave the place. The food, the bar, all first rate and the view....off the hook good. If the choice is between SSI and CFSG, I prefer the Gardens. It is more private, quiet, and right across the road from LTU pub. That said, a lot of people, and I mean many many people like SSI. It is a bit livelier with good food and bar, and a larger pool.