I don't know about cheesy but I can say overated would be Ricks Cafe!!! They boost that it has the best sunsets on the island (which cliff location doesn't??), best atmosphere (if you like a bunch of crowds), allows you to jump from the cliff and see "professional" divers jump (you can do that from any cliff location and you have to "donate" to get them to jump which you can see them from one of the other close by locations)........... I could go on but I will stop there.
so my vote is Ricks Cafe.
