Been to Bermuda, Aruba 2x, Cancun 2x, St Lucia and since 2006 Jamaica 2x a year. No need to even try another island. It has everything we need in a beach vacation. We do love traveling the US and use to get a 3rd trip each year to SC, FL, AZ etc etc but not in the last few years. Hubby made me promise I won't ask him to go to Mexico ever again!