I absolutely LOVE Natania's - probably my favorite place to stay in Jamaica. There's another guesthouse down the road from there too that we would stay at if Natania's was full - South Sea View. That's a nice place to stay too. I was worried with the big Sandals in Whitehouse that it would spoil the area - we used to walk on the beach where Sandals is now - it was absolutely deserted except for some fishing boats and the random stray cow/goat.