Jeannie,

We rented from Island Car at the airport. We got a Suzuki Grand Vitara which was a small SUV and super nice. Go to the Island Car website. The cost depends on age and whether you buy the insurance. We didn't have one person ask us for a ride. You're pretty insulated inside of a car which was nice after hanging out there for so many years on a scooter. I highly recommend it. We did have to call ahead once or twice to ask where we should park at a few of the resturants but they always had a place.

Enjoy!