Beth Ann and I are picky eaters. I don't do most veggies and she doesn't want to add any new animals to her her diet (i.e. goat). However, I found that when we were there I ate and enjoyed foods that I wouldn't normally touch. We intend to sample a lot more and different food this trip. The places we will certainly return to on our next visit:
3 Dives - The seasoned butter they serve with their lobster is dreamy
DeBar - The Jerk Chicken is great. We had a great time there in general
Teddy's Hideaway - Not only is Teddy's food good but conveniently located for us.
Jerk barrel guy across from BCC next to L&M - Forget his name (someone posted it on the board not too long ago)
Places that are on our to do list that we didn't get a chance to hit last trip:
Chicken Lavish
Ciao Jamaica
Canoe
Pee Wee's - Spent a lot of time there drinking last time but will have to try Elvis's cooking this trip
Bentley's