I responded to your post on TA, but here's a copy for others interested:

Enjoy Nirvana, we were there for our third visit over New Years.

Favorites from our recent trip:

Rainbow Arch right next to White Sands, order and come back an hour later to pick it up for lunch, or eat there. Most things are very good, all homemade, but very slow.

Alfred's for fish and chips

Niah's

Jerk Barrel across the street

Cosmo's if you want a long walk, or they will pick you up.

We walked down to Kuyaba one night, decent food, huge portions, but too touristy for us

Chill Awhile- Reggae band on Friday's, good service. Good breakfast too.

Jerk Pork from Dean who walks the beach, raises his own hogs

We tended to go to the West End for dinner most nights, Canoe, LTU, Eddie's Debar, 3 Dives.
Hard to beat walking to dinner without even bringing shoes though.