Your report was nearly identical to my experiences back in November. I felt the same about Presley's, large portions, but not great. I had a family of lobster there, and it was just... Meh.

Seastar service was as usual, wonderful (love Barbara), but the Saturday night buffet was not in any way what I would call good.

I love Ivan's, even though we do not stay there, and rock house is one of the best high end places you can find on the west end in my opinion.