We stayed at BCC and were married there in 2011. Stayed there over Christmas/New Years (2011/12), and seriously loved this place.
No witnesses for our wedding, just the two of us. Petrona went out of her way to make us feel special and very at home. Helped me get flowers/cake when nothing was open (married on 12/26, which was Boxing Day).
We had a room that looked directly out to the ocean in the middle of the property (not in the "castle" section, but in the middle area). We had a glitch with our Pastor, and they were wonderful at keeping our wedding area cleared of others.
The guests that were there were AWESOME. You can see they have a regular cult following, so many of the guests at our stay were regulars. That was wonderful.
Though we had been to JA many times before, this was truly a magical place. Petrona and Susan made everyone feel special. No issues with anything.
The best part, though, was that we really felt SAFE. The guard was friendly and on top of things, and no outsiders came in. Never did I lock my stuff up (I know, probably not smart) - but it really was like a family.
They are in a great location (No Limit was across the street, and Bentley's was a stones throw away). Would stay again in a heartbeat.