We're relatively newbies...three trips in last 4 years ( missed one due to illness). To me, the positive experience you will have is based in part by your own expectations. Go with an open mind and heart. Be curious and respectful and learn to fit into the rhythm of the island. Learn to let go and take time to do Nothing! (its a noble activity) I appreciate every moment and this amazing opportunity...not just the shocking beauty of the turquoise sea and the riotous colours of nature but more importantly the welcoming and patient people of Jamaica. There are old hats here and newbies. You can learn from both!